The Saber of Imam Tashu-Khaji from Sayasan: to the question of the authenticity of one exhibitor
https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2023-4-277-290
EDN: JSXZVZ
Abstract
The authors of the essay endeavored to research facts from the military history of the Caucasian War that are related with Tashu-Hadji Sayasanovsky, a campaigner for the third Imam Shamil and a notable leader of the movement for gazavat and Sharia in Chechnya and Dagestan. The study’s major plot is associated with the examination of the legitimacy of the bladed weapon, the owners of which claim it to be a trophy saber of Imam Tashu-Hadji. Despite the local context of this historical event, the circumstances associated with the person of Tashu-Hadji naturally increase the collection value of the saber. Summarizing the information about the military campaigns in which Tashu-Hadji took part, the authors expressed their opinion about the most likely circumstances when the saber could actually fall into the hands of the Russian military. The paper pays special emphasis on the examination and analysis of the exhibit owners’ arguments. The authors conclude that, despite the verisimilar and plausible arguments, there are numerous inconsistencies and contradictions in the information about the saber of Imam Tashu-Hadji, which is stated by its owners. Thus, the authenticity of the attribution of this collection item is called into question. The article’s materials were published historical evidence, presented by memoirs of Caucasus conquest participants, official correspondence of Russian military officials, works of military historians contemporaneous with the events, and Arabic-language works of Caucasian Muslim authors.
About the Authors
Abdulla Khamidovich Daudov
St. Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Dmitry Vladislavovich Ovsjannikov
St. Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. AD-DURGELI N. Uslada umov v biografiyah uchenyh Dagestana (Nuzkhat al-azkhān fū tarādzhim ‘ulamā’ Dāgistān): dagestanskie uchenye X–XX vv. i ih sochineniya. [The delight of the minds in the biographies of scientists of Dagestan. Dagestani scientists of the X–XX centuries and their writings]. – M.: Mardzhani Publ., 2012. – 223 p. (In Russ.).
2. ADZHAMATOV B.A. Stranicy istorii drevnego Endireya. Imam Tashav-hadzhi. [Pages of the history of ancient Andirey. Imam Tashav-haji.]. – Mahachkala: Dagpress Media, 2019. – 208 p. (In Russ.).
3. AHMADOV Sh.B. Remeslennye zanyatiya chechencev i ingushej v XVIII – XIX vv. [Crafts of Chechens and Ingush in the 18th – 19th centuries]. IN Voprosy politicheskogo i ekonomicheskogo razvitiya Checheno-Ingushetii (XVIII – nach. XX veka). – Groznyj, 1986. – P. 45–59. (In Russ.).
4. AKTY, sobrannyye Kavkazskoy arkheograficheskoy komissiyey. [Acts collected by the Cauca-sian Archaeographic Commission]. Т. VIII. – Tiflis: Type. Main Directorate of the Viceroy of the Caucasus, 1881. – 1033 p.
5. AL-KARAHI M.T. Hronika Muhammeda Tahira al-Karahi o dagestanskih vojnah v period Shamilya. [The Chronicle of Muhammad Tahir al-Karahi about the Dagestan wars during the Shamil period]. – M.-L.: Nauka Publ., 1941. – 336 p. (In Russ.).
6. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Istoriya oruzhejnogo i serebryanogo proizvodstva na Kavkaze v XIX – nachale XX v. Dagestan i Zakavkaz'e. [The history of weapons and silver production in the Caucasus in the XIX – early XX century. Dagestan and Transcaucasia]. P. I-II. – М.: Nauka Publ, 1977. – 259 p. (In Russ.).
7. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Mastera serebryanogo dela Zakavkaz'ya v XIX – nachale XX v. Spravochnik. [Silversmiths of Transcaucasia in the XIX – early XX century. The Guide]. P. I-II. – М.: Nauka Publ, 1978. – 249 p. (In Russ.).
8. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Ukazatel' klejm i imen kavkazskih masterov oruzhejnogo i serebry-anogo dela. [Index of brands and names of Caucasian masters of armory and silversmithing]. – М.: Nauka Publ, 1982. – 259 p. (In Russ.).
9. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Oruzhie narodov Kavkaza: istoriya oruzhiya. [Weapons of the peoples of the Caucasus: the history of weapons]. – M.: Hobbikniga; Nal'chik: «El'-Fa», 1995. – 191 p. (In Russ.).
10. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Dagestanskoe oruzhie. [Dagestan weapons]. – Mahachkala: Epo-ha, 2009. – 214 p. (In Russ.).
11. ASTVACATURYAN E.G. Oruzhie narodov Kavkaza. [Weapons of the peoples of the Cauca-sus]. – S-Pb.: Atlant, 2016. – 516 p. (In Russ.).
12. ASKHABOV I.A. Chechenskoe oruzhie. [Chechen weapons]. – M.: Klub «Kavkaz», 2001. – 238 p. (In Russ.).
13. GOLOVIN E.A. Ocherk polozheniya del na Kavkaze s nachala 1838 do konca 1842 goda. [Es-say on the state of affairs in the Caucasus from the beginning of 1838 to the end of 1842]. In: Kavkazskij sbornik. T. II. – Tiflis: Tipografiya Okruzhnogo shtaba Kavkazskogo Voennogo Okur-ga,1877. – P. 1-74. (In Russ.).
14. HANMURZAEV I.I. O poeticheskom proizvedenii Tashava-Hadzhi al-Indiri «O, spras-hivayushchij menya, o gospodah imamah». [About the poetic work of Tashawa-Haji al-Indir “O, ask-ing me about the Lord Imams”]. IN Osmanovskie chteniya. Sbornik materialov II Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii (g. Mahachkala, 12 oktyabrya 2017 g.). – Mahachkala: DGU Publ., 2017. – P. 168–173. (In Russ.).
15. FEDOROV V.G. Holodnoe oruzhie. [Cold steel arms]. – M. Yauza-Eksmo, 2010. – 288 p. (In Russ.).
16. KEMPER 2002 – Kemper M. Khalidiyya Networks in Dagestan and the Question of Jihad // Die Welt des Islams. – 2002 – Vol. 42 – Issue 1. – P. 41–71.
17. KEMPER M. K voprosu o sufijskoj osnove dzhihada v Dagestane. [On the issue of the Sufi basis of jihad in Dagestan]. In: Podvizhniki islama: Kul't svyatyh v Srednej Azii i na Kavkaze. – M: Vost. Lit. Publ. – P. 278–305. (In Russ.).
18. KRUGOV A.I., Nechitajlov M.V. Vooruzhennye sily imamata gorcev Severnogo Kavkaza 1829-1859 gg. [Armed forces of the Imamate of the North Caucasus mountaineers 1829-1859]. – M.: Ratnoe delo, 2016. – 175 p. (In Russ.).
19. LENC E.E. O klejmah masterov na oruzhii. [About the marks of masters on weapons]. IN Zapiski razryada voennoj arheologii i arheografii imperatorskogo russkogo voenno-istoricheskogo obshchestva. Т. I. – SPb.: Tipografiya Glavnogo Upravleniya Udelov, 1911. – P. 2–29. (In Russ.).
20. MARGGRAF O.V. Ocherki kustarnyh promyslov Severnogo Kavkaza s opisaniem tekhniki proizvodstva. [Essays on handicrafts of the North Caucasus with descriptions of production tech-niques]. – M.: Tipografiya S.V. Gur'yanova, 1882. – 328 p. (In Russ.).
21. MILLER Yu.A. Hudozhestvennoe oruzhie Gruzii XVII–XIX vv. Katalog vremennoj vystavki. [Artistic weapons of Georgia of the 17th-19th centuries. Temporary exhibition catalog]. – L., 1986. – 29 p. (In Russ.).
22. MILYUTIN D.A. Opisanie voennyh dejstvij 1839 goda v Severnom Dagestane. [Description of military operations in 1839 in Northern Dagestan]. – SPb.: Tip. voen. ucheb. zavedenij, 1850. – 144 p. (In Russ.).
23. ORAZAEV G.M-R., Hanmurzaev I.I. Tashav-hadzhi iz Endireya - geroj Kavkazskoj vojny (Sbornik issledovanij i materialov). [Tashav-haji from Endirey - hero of the Caucasian War (Collec-tion of research and materials)] / Ed. G.M.-R. Orazaev, I.I. Hanmurzaev. – Mahachkala, 2023. – 330 p. (In Russ.).
24. PROZRITELEV G.N. Kavkazskoe oruzhie (oruzhie kavkazskih gorcev). [Caucasian weapons (weapons of the Caucasian highlanders)]. – Stavropol': tip. Gub. pravl., 1915. – 18 p. (In Russ.).
25. SPISOK generalam po starshinstvu: Ispravleno po 1-ye Yanvarya. [List of generals by seniori-ty: Corrected to 1st January]. – St. Petersburg: Military Printing House, 1885.
26. TAMOJKIN M.Yu. Famil'nyj muzej Tamojkinyh. [Tamoykin Family Museum]. – Vil'nyus: «Arx-Baltica», 2004. – 200 p. (In Russ.).
27. TASHU-HADZHI Ummul h'isan. – Groznyj., 2011. – 464 p. (In Chechen)
28. YUROV A. Tri goda na Kavkaze (1837-1839). [Three years in the Caucasus (1837-1839)]. IN Kavkazskij sbornik. T. IX. – Tiflis: Tipografiya A.A. Mihel'sona,1885. P. 1–155. (In Russ.).
29. ZAKS A.B. Iz istorii pervogo perioda Imamata Shamilya. Tashav hadzhi – naib Shamilya. [From the history of the first period of Shamil’s Imamat. Tashav Haji - Naib of Shamil]. In: Tashav-hadzhi iz Endireya – geroj Kavkazskoj vojny (Sbornik issledovanij i materialov). – Mahachkala. P. 20-154. (In Russ.).
30. ZAKS A.B. Tashev-Hadzhi – spodvizhnik Shamilya. [Tashev-Hadji – Shamil's associate]. – Groznyj: Book Publ., 1992. – 32 p. (In Russ.).
31. ZISSERMAN A.L. Istoriya 80-go pekhotnogo Kabardinskogo general-fel'dmarshala Knyazya Baryatinskogo polka. (1726-1880). [The history of the 80th Kabardian Infantry General Field Mar-shal Prince Baryatinsky Regiment. (1726-1880)]. – T. 2. – SPb.: tip. V. Gracianskogo, 1881. – 470 p. (In Russ.).
32. ZNAMYONA gorskih voinov. [Banners of the Highland Warriors]. In: Rodina. – 1994. – № 3-4. – P. 76-77. (In Russ.).
Review
For citations:
Daudov A.Kh., Ovsjannikov D.V. The Saber of Imam Tashu-Khaji from Sayasan: to the question of the authenticity of one exhibitor. Kavkazologiya. 2023;(4):277-290. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2023-4-277-290. EDN: JSXZVZ
Views:
10
Email this article 