ILLIBERAL PEACEBUILDING AND REGIONAL POLITICAL DYNAMICS IN POST-SOVIET RUSSIA
https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2021-4-205-232
EDN: RAGAQH
Abstract
Over the post-Soviet period, the North Caucasus has been in the focus of Russian peacebuilding practices. Analysing the developments in Kabardino-Balkaria, we demonstrated the causal relationship between stabilisation by the federal centre and regional political dynamics. We used the framework drawn from conflict studies to interpret the strategies implemented by the national government and political settlement analysis to describe the dominant political settlements that emerged under the successive heads of the republic. The first political settlement was a result of institutional arrangement within a broad elite coalition with the late-Soviet nomenklatura in its foundation. Indirect rule by Moscow amounted to transfers of budget subventions in exchange for the provision of relative stability in the region. In the early 2000s, this political settlement failed to effectively respond to internal political problems; amidst federal recentralisation, the new political settlement was established in the republic. It was marked by reduced inclusivity of elites and greater dependence on the federal centre. This political settlement lacked success in tackling complications of elite cleavages and religious violence. In 2013, Moscow replaced the republican governor and constructed a new institutional arrangement with larger subservience to federal elites and substantial attention to security matters. Thus, peacebuilding practices implemented by the centre sought to stabilise the situation in the region; it resulted in a successful tightening of vertical elite control but at the cost of reducing the inclusiveness of the political system within Kabardino-Balkaria.
About the Author
A. A. TUMOV
Kabardino-Balkarian State University named after H.M. Berbekov
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. APAZHEVA E.Kh. Nacional'nyi vopros i mezhnacional'nye otnosheniya na Severnom Kavkaze 1985-2000 gg. [National issue and interethnic relations in the North Caucasus, 1985–2000]. – M.: BIBLIO-GLOBUS, 2018. – 200 p. (In Russian)
2. ASHKHOTOVA M.R. Modernizaciya mehanizma regulirovaniya zemel'nyh otnoshenii v usloviyah malozemel'ya: diss. … kand. ekonom. nauk [Modernisation of land tenure regulation amidst land shortage: dissertation … of the candidate of economic sciences degree]. – Nalchik: V.M. Kokov KBGAU, 2015. – 160 p. (In Russian)
3. BOROV A.Kh. Evolyutsiya politicheskih institutov Kabardino-Balkarskoi Respubliki v 1990-h – 2010-h godah: faktory, tendencii, predvaritel'nye itogi [Evolution of political institutions in Kabardino-Balkarian Republic in the 1990–2010s: factors, tendencies, preliminary results]. IN: Aktual'nye problemy social'no-politicheskogo i etnokul'turnogo razvitiya sovremennoi Kabardino-Balkarii. – Nalchik: KBNC RAN, 2017. – P. 4–69. (In Russian)
4. BOROV A.Kh., DUMANOV Kh.M., KAZHAROV V.Kh. Sovremennaya gosudarstvennost' Kabardino-Balkarii: istoki, pusti stanovleniya, problem [Modern statehood of Kabardino-Balkaria: roots, formation, issues]. – Nalchik: El'-Fa, 1999. – 183 p. (In Russian)
5. BOROV A.Kh., DZAMIKHOV K.F., MAMSIROV Kh.B. Regional'nyi opyt politicheskih transformaciya v noveishei istorii Rossii: Kabardino-Balkarskaya Respublika [Regional experience of political transformations in contemporary Russian history: the case of the Kabardino-Balkarian Republic]. IN: Noveishaia istoriya Rossii. – Vol. 8. – No. 3. – P. 691–707. (In Russian)
6. BOROV A.Kh., TUMOV A.A. Elity i postsovetskaya transformaciya politicheskih rezhimov v respublikah Severnogo Kavkaza: ‘sluchai’ Kabardino-Balkarii [Elites and post-Soviet transformation of political regimes in the North Caucasus republics: the case of Kabardino-Balkaria]. IN: Istoricheskii zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya. – 2017. – No. 4. – P. 40–55. (In Russian)
7. CHENG C., GOODHAND J., MEEHAN P. Securing and Sustaining Elite Bargains that Reduce Violent Conflict. Synthesis Paper. – London: UK Stabilisation Unit, 2018. (In English)
8. DERLUGIAN G. Bourdieu’s Secret Admirer in the Caucasus. – New-York: Verso, 2004. – 408 p. (In English)
9. GAMMER M. Separatism in the Northern Caucasus. IN: Caucasus Survey. – 2014. – Vol. 1. – No. 2. – P. 37–47. (In English)
10. GEL'MAN V.Y. (2006) Vozvrashhenie Leviafana? Politika recentralizacii v sovremennoi Rossii [The return of Leviathan? Recentralisation politics in post-Soviet Russia]. IN: Polis. – 2006. – No. 2. – P. 90–109. (In Russian)
11. GEL'MAN V.Y. 2019 «Nedostoinoe pravlenie»: politika v sovremennoi Rossii [Bad governance: politics in modern Russia]. – Saint-Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, 2019. – 254 p. (In Russian)
12. GELMAN V.Y. Russia’s Elites in Search of Consensus: What Kind of Consolidation? IN: Demokratizatsya. The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization. – 2002. – Vol. 10. – No. 3. – P. 343–361. (In English)
13. GEL'MAN V.Y., STARODUBTSEV A.V. Vozmozhnosti i ogranicheniya avtoritarnoi modernizacii: rossiiskie reformy 2000-h godov [Opportunities and limites of authoritarian modenisation: reforms in the 2000s Russia]. IN: Politeia. – 2014. – No. 4. – P. 6–30. (In Russian)
14. GOLOSOV G.V. Co-optation in the Process of Dominant Party System Building: the Case of Russia. IN: East European Politics. – 2014. – Vol. 30. – No. 2. – P. 271–285. (In English)
15. GOLOSOV G.V. Legislative Turnover and Executive Control on Russia’s Regions (2003–2014). IN: Europe-Asia Studies. – 2017. – Vol. 69. – No. 4. – P. 553–570. (In English)
16. GRATZ J. Russia’s Military Reform: Progress and Hurdles. IN: CSS Analyses in Security Policy. – 2014. – No. 152. – P. 1–4. (In English)
17. HAJKIN S.R., POPOV N.P. (Protestnye nastroeniya na Severnom Kavkaze: obshhee i osobennoe [Disaffection in the North Caucasus: generalities and particularities]. IN: Monitoring obshhestvennogo mneniya (chast' I). – 2012. – No. 4. – P. 14–28. (In Russian)
18. HOLLAND E.C. Economic Development and Subsidies in the North Caucasus. IN: Problems of Post-Communism. – 2016. – Vol. 63. – No. 1. – P. 50–61. (In English)
19. HOLLAND E.C., WITMER F.D.W., O’LOUGHLIN J. The Decline and Shifting Geography of Violence in Russia’s North Caucasus, 2010–2016. IN: Eurasian Geography and Economics. – 2017. – Vol. 58. – No. 6. – P. 613–641. (In English)
20. KAHN J. The Parade of Sovereignties: Establishing the Vocabulary of the New Russian Federalism. IN: Post-Soviet Affairs. – 2000. – Vol. 16. – No. 1. – P. 58–89. (In English)
21. KAZENIN K.I. «Tihie konflikty» na Severnom Kavkaze. Adygeya, Kabardino-Balkariya, Karachaevo-Cherkesiya [Silent conflicts in the North Caucasus: Adygea, Kabardin-Balkaria, Karachay-Cherkesia]. – M.: REGNUM, 2009. – 180 p. (In Russian)
22. KEEN M. Assessing authoritarian conflict management in the Middle East and Central Asia. IN: Conflict, Security, and Development. – 2021. – Vol. 21. – No. 3. – P. 245–272. (In English)
23. KHAN M. Political Settlements and the Analysis of Institutions. IN: African Affairs. – 2018. – No. 117. – P. 636–655. (In English)
24. KOEHLER J., GUNYA A., SHOGENOV M., TUMOV A. Violence and the Dynamics of Political Settlements in Post-Soviet Kabardino-Balkaria. IN: Perspectives on Terrorism. – 2020. – Vol. 14. – No. 2. – P. 93–111, 233–236. (In English)
25. LEWIS D., HEATHERSHAW J., MEGORAN N. Illiberal peace? Authoritarian Modes of Conflict Management. IN: Cooperation and Conflict. – 2018. – Vol. 53. – No. 4. – P. 486–506. (In English)
26. LITVINOVA T.N. Politicheskie instituty na Severnom Kavkaze v kontekste razvitiya rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti [Political institutions in the North Caucasus amidst evolution of Russian statehood]. – Saarbrjukken: Lambert Academic Publishing, 2011. – 292 p. (In Russian)
27. MELVIN N. Building Stability in the North Caucasus. Ways Forward for Russia and the European Union. SIPRI Policy Paper No. 16. – Stockholm: SIPRI, 2007. – 59 p. (In English)
28. PABST A. «Tretii put'» Dmitriya Medvedeva [‘The third path’ of Dmitry Medvedev]. IN: Rossiya v global'noi politike. – 2010. – No. 5. – P. 23–34. (In Russian)
29. PEARCE J. Peace-building in the Periphery: Lessons from Central America. IN: Third World Quarterly. – 1999. – Vol. 20. – No. 1. – P. 51–68. (In English)
30. PLONSKI S., YOUSUF Z. Borderlands and Peacebuilding: a View from the Margins. PSRP Report, Accord. Conciliation Resources, 2018 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.politicalsettlements.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Accord-Insight-4-Borderlands-WEB.pdf (access date: 21.10.2021). (In English)
31. Politicheskoe razvitie Rossii. 2014–2016: Instituty i praktiki avtoritarnoi konsolidacii [Political development of Russia. 2014-2016. Institutions and patterns of authoritarian consolidation. Ed. By K. Rogov]. – Moscow: Fond «Liberal'naya Missiya», 2016. – 216 p. (In Russian)
32. President Decree No. 1232 «O merah po gosudarstvennoi podderzhke social'no-ekonomicheskogo polozheniya KBR» [On the state support for socio-economic situation in KBR], 14 October 1992 g. IN: Kabardino-Balkarskaya Pravda. – 20 October 1992. – No. 202. – P. 1. (In Russian)
33. ROSS C. Federalism and Democratization in Russia. – Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2002. – 182 p. (In English)
34. Severnyi Kavkaz: modernizacionnyi vyzov [The North Caucasus: the challenge of modernization. Ed. by I.V Starodubrovskaya]. – Moscow: Izdatel'skii dom «Delo» RANHiGS, 2011. – 328 p. (In Russian)
35. Severnyi Kavkaz: Vzgliad iznutri. Vyzovy i problemy social'no-politicheskogo razvitiya [The North Caucasus: The view from inside. Challenges and problems of socio-political development. Ed. By A.G. Matveeva]. – Moscow: Institut Vostokovedeniya RAN, 2012. – 172 p. (In Russian)
36. SHIPILOV V.I., KUZ'MINA S.V. Istoriya milicii Kabardino-Balkarii: etapy sozdaniya, stanovleniya i razvitiya [The history of militsia in Kabardino-Balkaria: making, formation, and evolution]. – Nalchik: Izdatel'stvo M. i V. Kotlyarovyh, 2007. – 376 p. (In Russian)
37. SHOROVA M.B. Nacional'nyi vopros v obshhestvenno-politicheskoi zhizni Kabardino-Balkarii (seredina 1980-h – 1990-e gg.): diss. … k.i.n. [National issue in socio-political life of Kabardino-Balkaria (mid 1980s – 1990s): dissertation … of the candidate of historical sciences degree]. – Nalchik, 2010. – 206 p. (In Russian)
38. SOULEIMANOV E. An Ethnography of Counterinsurgency: Kadyrovtsy and Russia's Policy of Chechenization. IN: Post-Soviet Affairs. – 2015. – Vol. 31. – No. 2. – P. 91–114. (In English)
39. STARODUBROVSKAJA I.V., KAZENIN K.I. Severnyi Kavkaz i sovremennaya model' demokraticheskogo razvitiya [The North Caucasus and the contemporary trajectory of democratisation]. – Moscow: Komitet grazhdanskih iniciativ, 2016. – 69 p. (In Russian)
40. STARODUBROVSKAJA I.V., KAZENIN K.I. Severnyi Kavkaz: Quo vadis? [The North Caucasus. Quo vadis?] – Moscow: Komitet grazhdanskih iniciativ, 2013. – 67 p. (In Russian)
41. STARODUBROVSKAJA I.V., SOKOLOV D.V. Istoki konfliktov na Severnom Kavkaze [The origins of conflicts in the North Caucasus]. – Moscow: Izdatel'skii dom «Delo» RANHiGS, 2013. – 280 p. (In Russian)
42. TAKOVA A.N. «Molyashhayasya» musul'manskaya molodezh' kak subkul'tura kabardino-balkarskogo obshhestva [‘Praying’ musclim youth as a subculture of the Kabardino-Balkarian society]. IN: Gosudarstvo, religiya, cerkov' v Rossii i za rubezhom. – 2016. – No. 2. – P. 255–280. (In Russian)
43. The North Caucasus: The Challenges of Integration (III): Governance, Elections, Rule of Law. Europe Report No. 226, 2012. – 48 p. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/522d78cf4.pdf (access date: 21.10.2021). (In English)
44. TOFT M.D., ZHUKOV Y.M. Denial and Punishment in the North Caucasus: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Coercive Counter-Insurgency. IN: Journal of Peace Research. – 2012. Vol. 49. – No. 6. – P. 785–800. (In English)
45. TSUTSIEV A.A. Atlas etnopoliticheskoi istorii Kavkaza [The North Caucasus atlas of ethnopolitical history] (1774–2004). – M.: Evropa, 2007. – 128 p. (In Russian)
46. TUMOV A.A. Izbiratel'nyi process v sovremennoi Kabardino-Balkarii: evolyuciya politicheskih uslovii, ustoichivost' politicheskih rezul'tatov [Electoral process in modern Kabardino-Balkaria: evolution of political conditions, stability of political results]. IN: Elektronnyi zhurnal «Kavkazologiya». – 2017. – No. 2. – P. 119–139. – DOI: https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2017-2-119-139 (In Russian)
47. TUMOV A.A. Tendencii i problemy politicheskogo razvitiya respublik Severnogo Kavkaza v postsovetskii period: opyt Kabardino-Balkarii: diss. … k.i.n. [Tendencies and problems of political development in the North Caucasus republics: the case of Kabardino-Balkaria: dissertation … of the candidate of historical sciences degree]. – Nalchik, 2020. – 345 p. (In Russian)
48. TUMOV A.A., TATAROV A.A., MASHUKOV H.V. Kabardino-Balkariya v 2014–2019 godah: v poiskah resheniya staryh problem [Kabardin-Balkaria in 2014–2019: in the quest for solutions to the old problems]. IN: Elektronnyi zhurnal «Kavkazologiya». – 2019. – No. 4. – P. 112–127. – DOI: https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2019-4-112-127 (In Russian)
49. YEMELIANOVA G.M. Kinship, ethnicity and religions in post-Communist societies. IN: Ethnicities. – 2005. – No. 5. – P. 51–82. (In English)
50. YOUNGMAN M. Crossing the Rubicon. IN: Perspectives on Terrorism. – 2020. – Vol. 14. – No. 6. – P. 106–121. (In English)
51. Yuri Kokov: bor'ba s ekstremizmom – ne vo vred ekonomike [Yuri Kokov: combatting extremism without harming the economy]. IN: Gazeta Yuga. – 12 December 2013. – No. 40. – P. 1. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
TUMOV A.A. ILLIBERAL PEACEBUILDING AND REGIONAL POLITICAL DYNAMICS IN POST-SOVIET RUSSIA. E-Journal “Kavkazologiya”. 2021;(4):205-232. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212X-2021-4-205-232. EDN: RAGAQH
Views:
3
Email this article 